You list a $40 item and someone offers $12. Cue the eye roll. Lowball offers are part of selling on Mercari – and honestly, they’re not the villain they feel like. Handled right, plenty of them turn into real sales. Here’s how to deal without getting annoyed or giving your stuff away.
Why lowballs happen
Most lowballers aren’t trying to insult you. They’re bargain hunters testing the water, and a lot of them fully expect a counter. Some are new and don’t know the etiquette. A few are just fishing. The point is: an offer, even a bad one, means someone is interested enough to tap the button. That’s a lead, not an attack.
How to respond
Keep it simple and unemotional:
- Counter, almost always. Even a lowball deserves a polite counter near your real bottom price. You’ll be surprised how often they say yes.
- Meet in the middle when it’s close. If they’re within a few dollars of a fair price, take it and move the item.
- Decline politely on the absurd ones. A one-tap decline or a friendly “thanks, I can’t go that low” is fine. No lecture needed.
- Never take it personally. It’s business. A quick counter beats a grudge every time.
Price so lowballs stop stinging
The secret pros know: build negotiating room into your price. List a little above your true bottom line so there’s space to come down and still profit. When you price with a cushion, a lowball counter still lands you a fair sale – and you look generous doing it. If your prices are razor-thin, every offer feels like an insult. Give yourself room.
Let the system handle the busywork
Fielding offers across a big catalog on multiple platforms gets old fast. This is where having your shop actually organized pays off. Nifty handles your listings and crosslisting with AI and detects your sales, so when an offer turns into a sale on one marketplace, you’re flagged to pull the item from the others – no double-selling while you’re mid-negotiation. Your shop stays clean while you focus on the deals worth making.
Want the full system for pricing, offers, and running a hands-off shop? It’s all in my AI Reselling Playbook.
Bottom line
Lowballs aren’t disrespect, they’re interest with a bad opening bid. Counter politely, build room into your prices, and decline the wild ones without a second thought. Keep your cool and a chunk of those offers become sales. Do less, earn more.
New here? Nifty is the AI crosslister I use to list once and sell everywhere – and if you want in, my code ALEXIS44 gets you 15% off: https://nifty.ai/?referral=ALEXIS44